PardonReady is not a law firm and is not part of the government. Applying is free and no lawyer is required. Nothing here is legal advice about your situation.
Nothing here predicts what the President will do.
Guide 5
Letters of support for a pardon: the three-letter rule
The last section of the pardon application is the one you cannot finish alone. Section M asks other people to speak for you. The rules are short, and people get them wrong often.
The rule in the form's words
The application's checklist asks for "3 signed letters of support from non-relatives". Section M explains:
"We need at least three letters. If you give us more than three letters, let us know which three will be your primary references."
And then the rule that trips people up:
"Primary references cannot be related to you by blood or marriage and must be willing to be interviewed during a background investigation."
So there are three tests for each of your three primary references:
- They are not related to you by blood.
- They are not related to you by marriage. That rules out a spouse and in-laws.
- They are willing to be interviewed. A pardon application can lead to an FBI background investigation, and investigators may call the people who wrote for you.
Each letter on the form's template includes this line for the writer to complete: "I certify that I have personally known the petitioner for ___ years and am not related to petitioner by blood or marriage."
What the rule does not say
It helps to notice what is missing, because people add rules that are not there.
- The form does not set a minimum number of years the writer must have known you.
- It does not say the writer must have known you since before the conviction, or only after it.
- It does not say the writers must hold any title or position.
It also does not say family cannot write at all. The form asks for "at least three" letters and asks you to mark three as primary. In our reading, a letter from your mother or your spouse can be a fourth or fifth letter. It cannot be one of the three primary ones. That is our reading of the form's words, not a statement from the Justice Department.
Who makes a good reference?
The form does not rank writers. So here is practical thinking, in our words.
A useful letter comes from someone who knows your life now and can describe it with specifics. Think about who sees you regularly: an employer or supervisor, a co-worker, a neighbor, a pastor or faith leader, a person you volunteer with, a sponsor or mentor, a longtime friend.
Three things matter more than a title:
- They know about the conviction. A reference who is surprised by an investigator's call helps no one. The letter is for a pardon application, so the writer has to know that.
- They know you well enough to give details. "She is a good person" tells the reader little. "She has opened our food pantry every Saturday for four years" tells the reader something.
- They will pick up the phone. The form says primary references "must be willing to be interviewed."
Variety helps the reader see more of your life. Three letters from three co-workers at the same job show one part of it.
How to ask
Ask in person or by phone if you can. Then follow up in writing so the person has what they need. In our words, tell them:
- What you are applying for, and that the letter goes to the Justice Department's Office of the Pardon Attorney.
- That you have a federal conviction, and what it was for. Do not make them guess.
- That the form asks them to state how many years they have known you and that they are not related to you.
- That an investigator might contact them, and that this is a normal part of the process.
- That the letter must be signed.
- When you hope to send your application. Give them a few weeks.
Then let them write.
The letter must be theirs
This is the most important part of this guide.
Do not write the letter for them. Do not hand them a draft to sign. A letter of support is a statement by the person who signs it. It certifies facts in their name. If the words are yours, the letter is not what it claims to be, and the application carries a warning about false statements for a reason.
There is also a practical problem. If an investigator calls and the writer cannot speak to what "their" letter says, that hurts you far more than a short, plain letter would have.
You can tell a writer what the form asks for. You can answer their questions about the process. You should not tell them what to say about you. PardonReady does not write support letters and does not supply sample ones, for the same reason.
If a writer asks, "What should I say?" a fair answer is: "Say how you know me, for how long, and what you have seen of my life. Say it the way you would say it."
Common mistakes
- A relative as one of the three. A cousin, an uncle, a brother-in-law. All are related by blood or marriage.
- An unsigned letter. The checklist says "signed."
- A letter that does not state the relationship. The template asks the writer to certify the number of years and that they are not related.
- A writer who does not know about the conviction.
- Identical letters. Three letters with the same sentences look like one author.
- Sending more than three without marking the primary ones. The form asks you to "let us know which three will be your primary references."
Do the letters go in with the application?
The form treats the letters as part of the application package, in Section M. Whether the office accepts letters sent separately by the writers is not addressed on the form. The Justice Department's question-and-answer page does say that "A clemency applicant – or any third party – is free to send any documentation or other written information." The simplest path is to collect the three signed letters and send them with your application.
A note on the commutation form
Everything above is about the pardon application. The commutation petition has different sections and does not have the same three-letter rule. If you are helping someone who is still serving a sentence, read that form's own instructions.
Sources
- Application for Pardon After Completion of Sentence, checklist and Section M (pages 20–22) — justice.gov/pardon/file/960581/dl?inline (opening sentences re-read November 10, 2026; full Section M text last confirmed word for word October 5, 2026)
- Office of the Pardon Attorney, Frequently Asked Questions ("Updated September 9, 2026") — justice.gov/pardon/frequently-asked-questions