PardonReady is not a law firm and is not part of the government. Applying is free and no lawyer is required. Nothing here is legal advice about your situation.
Nothing here predicts what the President will do.
Guide 6
What the Justice Department says it looks at in a pardon application
Most people think the pardon process is a black box. Part of it is. But the Justice Department has published the standards its own staff use when they review a pardon application. They are in the Justice Manual, the Department's handbook for its lawyers, at section 9-140.112.
This guide sets out what the Department says. It will not tell you how to "match" the factors, and we explain why at the end.
First, who decides
The Justice Department describes the process in three stages on its website: the office investigates your application, it "recommends how the President should handle the application", and the President "decides to grant or deny the application."
So the standards below are the standards for the recommendation. The President is not bound by them. The Department's regulation says its rules "are advisory only" and do not "restrict the authority granted to the President."
The starting point
The Justice Manual opens its pardon standards with a general statement. A pardon, it says, is granted "on the basis of the petitioner's demonstrated good conduct for a substantial period of time". Then it lists five factors. The headings below are the Manual's, exactly as printed.
1. "Post-conviction conduct, character, and reputation."
This is the first factor listed, and the pardon form shows how much weight the office puts on it. Most of the form's 24 pages ask about life after the conviction: where you have lived, your jobs, your schooling, your community activities, your finances, your sobriety.
The background investigation checks this part. The form says primary references "must be willing to be interviewed during a background investigation."
2. "Seriousness and relative recentness of the offense."
The office looks at what the crime was and how long ago it happened. The waiting rule is connected to this. The Manual says the Department's regulations ask a person to "wait a period of at least five years after conviction or release from confinement (whichever is later) before filing a pardon application".
Five years is the floor in the rule. The Manual does not say that five years is enough for every offense, and it does not publish a schedule by type of crime.
3. "Acceptance of responsibility, remorse, and atonement."
This is the factor people worry about most. The Manual says that "a petitioner's attempt to minimize or rationalize culpability does not advance the case for pardon."
It also addresses people who say they did not do it: "Persons seeking a pardon on grounds of innocence or miscarriage of justice bear a formidable burden of persuasion."
The form asks about this directly, in its own words: "Do you accept responsibility for your conduct? Explain why or why not."
Notice that the form's question has two halves. It asks whether, and it asks why or why not. It does not tell you what to answer. We will not either. What you believe about your own conduct is yours to state truthfully. If your honest answer is complicated, for instance because you maintain you were wrongly convicted, please talk with a lawyer before you write it.
4. "Need for Relief."
Why do you need a pardon? The Manual gives an example of the kind of reason that can matter: "a specific employment-related need for pardon, such as removal of a bar to licensure or bonding".
Section B of the pardon form is where this goes. It asks your reasons for seeking a pardon, and it asks for letters showing that a job or license was refused because of the conviction, if you have them.
The Justice Department's question-and-answer page says a pardon "may be helpful in obtaining licenses, bonding, or employment." Note the word "may." A federal pardon does not order a state licensing board to do anything.
5. "Official recommendations and reports."
The office does not rely only on what you send. It gathers views from inside the government. The Justice Department's "How Clemency Works" page says that for a pardon, "we might ask the FBI to conduct a background investigation." The regulations also describe asking the prosecutor's office and the sentencing judge for their views, and there is a rule about notifying victims in certain cases.
You do not gather these. PardonReady never contacts a prosecutor, judge, victim or any government office for anyone, and we advise you not to ask someone to do it for you for a fee.
What the factors do not tell you
Here is the honest limit of this information.
They are not a scoring sheet. The Manual lists the factors. It does not give weights, cut-offs or examples of applications that succeeded.
They do not bind the President. Reporting over the past two years has described many grants that did not come through the Justice Department's review at all. A CBS News analysis published in September 2026 said that "About 70% of Mr. Trump's clemency actions in his second term were not routed through the Justice Department". We include that so you have the full picture of how decisions have been made lately. It is one outlet's analysis of Justice Department data. It says nothing about any one pending application.
Nobody publishes results by factor. The Justice Department's statistics page counts applications received, granted and denied. It does not say why. Real applications are not public. Anyone who claims to know "what works" is guessing or selling.
Why we will not coach you to the factors
It would be easy to turn the five factors into a checklist: "Show remorse here. Mention your volunteering there." We do not do that, for three reasons.
First, the application is a sworn statement. You certify under penalty of perjury that it is true. Words chosen to fit a factor rather than to tell the truth put you at risk.
Second, the office investigates. It talks to your references and may ask the FBI to look into your background. An application that reads well but does not match your life will not survive that.
Third, the form already asks the right questions. The Justice Department wrote its questions to draw out the information these factors need. If you answer every question the form prints, fully and truthfully, in your own words, you have given the office what it asked for.
So read the five factors to understand what the reader cares about. Then set them aside and answer the form.
Commutation uses different standards
Everything above is for pardons. For commutations, the Manual has a separate section, 9-140.113. It begins: "Commutation of sentence is an extraordinary remedy." It lists different grounds, and it says requests are generally not accepted from people "who are presently challenging their convictions or sentences through appeal or other court proceeding."
Sources
- Justice Manual 9-140.112 and 9-140.113 (page last modified November 16, 2023) — justice.gov/jm/jm-9-140000-pardon-attorney (factor headings and the sentences quoted re-read November 10, 2026)
- Office of the Pardon Attorney, "How Clemency Works" ("Updated July 1, 2024") — justice.gov/pardon/how-clemency-works
- 28 CFR 1.11 — law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/28/1.11
- Application for Pardon After Completion of Sentence — justice.gov/pardon/file/960581/dl?inline
- Office of the Pardon Attorney, Frequently Asked Questions — justice.gov/pardon/frequently-asked-questions
- CBS News / 60 Minutes, report on pardon lobbying with an analysis of Justice Department data (updated September 13, 2026) — cbsnews.com/news/trump-pardon-lobbyists-60-minutes/ (sentence last confirmed November 10, 2026)